Skip to main content
Treasure Idaho

New Projects

Legacy Farms in Caldwell Denied: City Council Votes 4-2 Against 373-Home Neighborhood

Landscape plan for the denied Legacy Farms Subdivision in Caldwell, showing home lots around a central park with a pool and pickleball courts near Northside Boulevard
Site plan: Jensen Belts Associates (filed with the City of Caldwell, via Boise Builds)

Article

CALDWELL — Update: The Caldwell City Council has denied Legacy Farms, the 373-home neighborhood planned on about 95 acres off Northside Boulevard in Caldwell. At its Monday, Nov. 16 meeting, the council voted 4-2 against the project, the Idaho Press reported. Council member Scott Tilmant made the motion to deny the annexation and preliminary plat, and council members Mike Dittenber and Geoff Williams voted against the denial.

A summary of the meeting drawn from the City of Caldwell's record says the council denied annexation for the Legacy Farm proposal and, as a result, took no action on its zoning or preliminary plat. Treasure Idaho previewed the Legacy Farms plan before the vote.

What Legacy Farms asked for

Porchlight Development, on behalf of property owner Gemini LLLP, asked the city to annex the land west of Northside Boulevard, north of Linden Road, zone it R-2 (Community Residential) and approve a preliminary plat (cases ANN26-000005 and SPP26-000003). The plan first called for 402 single-family lots and was cut to 373 after the Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission recommended denial on Sept. 9.

Residents stayed past 10 p.m. to speak against the project at the council hearing, listing concerns about density, lot sizes, water and public safety, according to the Idaho Press.

Gideon Landing and North Celeste move ahead

The council heard two other subdivisions near Midway Road and Moss Street the same night.

Gideon Landing is a 65-lot single-family neighborhood on nearly 15 acres, with 1.8 acres of open space planned for a walking path, a large central grass area, a play structure, shaded seating and a playing field. The council unanimously approved annexation, and the city's meeting summary says it also approved R-2 zoning. The preliminary plat was continued to the Dec. 7 meeting so city staff and the applicant can work out an easement agreement and a possible pedestrian path. The developer agreed to give the Vallivue School District $500 per home, or $32,500 in total, and offered to put a four-way stop at Midway Road and Moss Street, the Idaho Press reported.

North Celeste, two parcels down from Gideon Landing, is a 104-lot single-family subdivision on 19.93 acres. The council unanimously approved its annexation and preliminary plat. According to the city's meeting summary, conditions require stop signs at Moss and Midway before construction traffic begins, plus the developer's share of right-of-way and improvements at the Moss–Celeste and Midway–Moss intersections. The applicant also agreed to give the Vallivue School District $500 per lot.

More on Caldwell

Treasure Idaho has also covered the Residences at Wilson Creek groundbreaking and the Cleveland Boulevard and Linden Street intersection improvements. See the Caldwell city guide, browse new home communities in Caldwell, check homes for sale in Caldwell, or read more Caldwell growth news. Thank you for reading Treasure Idaho.

Moving guide

Moving to Idaho

A short guide from Treasure Idaho: regions, seasons, jobs, new-home communities, and the questions worth asking before you pick a town. Download it, then poke around the cities and the map.

Then look through the cities and the map.